Blog › Local Ads
Google Ads vs Local Services Ads: Which One Should a Local Business Run?
By Jason Stern · · Founder, Enlightened Media (Google Premier Partner)
Local Services Ads charge per lead, sit at the very top of Google, and need almost no keyword work, but you get little control over who sees them. Google Search ads charge per click and give you full control over keywords, budget and landing pages. If your industry qualifies for LSA, most local service businesses should run both and judge each by cost per booked job.
How Local Services Ads work
Local Services Ads (LSA) are the boxes at the top of the results with a business name, star rating, years in business and a verification badge. You do not pick keywords or write ad copy. You pick the job types and service areas you want, Google matches searches to your profile, and you pay when a customer contacts you, not when they click.
To get in, the business goes through Google's verification. Depending on the category and location that includes a background check on the owner and field workers, license verification, and proof of insurance. Home service businesses have historically earned the Google Guaranteed badge, and professional services like law firms and financial planners earned Google Screened. Google has been consolidating these into a single "Google Verified" label, so check what your own dashboard shows rather than relying on old screenshots.
What decides where you rank
Google does not let you buy the top spot outright. Ranking leans on factors you mostly control through operations, not budget:
- Proximity to the person searching
- Your review count and rating (Google reviews on your Business Profile and LSA profile)
- Responsiveness: how often you answer calls and how fast you reply to messages
- Business hours (being open when people search matters)
- Serious complaints against the business
- Your bid and budget, which still play a role
You can bid with "maximize leads" or set a max per lead. In the accounts I manage, missed calls hurt LSA more than anything else. A shop that lets calls go to voicemail at 4:30 pm slides down fast.
Disputing bad leads
Not every lead is billable. Wrong service, outside your area, spam and job seekers can be disputed in the lead inbox, and Google also credits some invalid leads automatically. Review leads every week. Dispute windows are limited, and credits you never request are money you never see.
How Google Search ads work
Search ads are the classic text ads labeled "Sponsored." You choose the keywords, write the headlines and descriptions, set the budget and bid strategy, and send people to a page you control. You pay per click whether that click turns into a call or not.
That control is the whole point. You can target "tankless water heater installation" and skip "water heater repair" if repair jobs are not worth it to you. You can add negative keywords, schedule ads by hour, adjust by location, and test offers. You can also send traffic to a dedicated page instead of your homepage, which is usually where the conversion rate gets won or lost (see our notes on Google Ads landing page design).
The tradeoff is that Search ads punish sloppy setup. Broad keywords, no negatives and weak tracking will burn budget on clicks that never call. That is the most common reason I see behind a cost per lead that is too high.
Which industries can run Local Services Ads
LSA is not available to everyone. In the US it covers a defined list of categories, and availability varies by city. Common eligible categories include:
- Home services: plumbing, HVAC, electrical, roofing, locksmith, pest control, garage door, appliance repair, cleaning, landscaping and similar trades
- Legal: many practice areas such as personal injury, criminal defense, family law and estate planning
- Professional services like real estate agents and financial planners
- Some health and wellness categories, in limited markets
Ecommerce, restaurants, most B2B companies, SaaS and plenty of niche services cannot run LSA at all. For them, Search ads are the only option on this page. Google changes the list over time, so check the LSA sign-up page for your exact category and zip code before making a plan.
Cost structure: pay per lead vs pay per click
The pricing models are different enough that comparing "cost per click" to "cost per lead" directly is a mistake. Compare what each one costs per booked job.
- LSA: you pay a set price per qualified lead. That price depends on your category, market and job type. There is no landing page cost and no wasted clicks, but you also cannot filter leads well before they reach you.
- Search ads: you pay per click. Cost per lead equals cost per click divided by your conversion rate. A $20 click with a 10% conversion rate is a $200 lead. Better landing pages and tighter keywords lower that number.
Set a ceiling for both with the same math. Max cost per lead = average job value x close rate x the share of revenue you are willing to spend to acquire the job. If an average job is $1,200, you close 40% of leads, and you will spend 15% of revenue on acquisition, your ceiling is about $72 per lead. If either channel is consistently above that, it needs fixing or cutting.
How LSA and Search ads interact on the results page
On most eligible searches, LSA shows first, then Search ads, then the map pack, then organic results. They are separate auctions, so running both does not make you bid against yourself. It gives you two shots at the same searcher, and in my experience that usually means more total leads, not the same leads split in two.
The overlap does show up in reporting. A customer may see your LSA, click a Search ad, then call from your Business Profile. Expect some double counting and judge the combined result as well as each channel alone.
When to run one, the other, or both
- LSA only: a small eligible business with a tight budget, solid reviews and someone answering the phone all day. It is simple to manage and the per lead price is predictable.
- Search ads only: your category is not eligible, or you need to target specific high value services that LSA lumps in with everything else.
- Both: an eligible business that wants volume and can handle it. LSA covers the top slot, Search ads pick up the specific, high margin searches and anything LSA does not show for.
If you are eligible and only want to start with one, I usually start with LSA because it needs less setup, then add Search once reviews and phone handling are dialed in. Our Local Services Ads management page covers what that setup involves.
Tracking both channels
LSA leads live in the LSA dashboard and lead inbox, with optional call recording. Search ads need conversion tracking you set up yourself: form submissions, calls from ads, and calls from the website. Without it, Smart Bidding is guessing. Here is how we handle conversion tracking setup.
- Turn on call recording in LSA and listen to a sample every week
- Mark each LSA lead as booked or not so you know your real close rate
- Track website calls and forms for Search ads as primary conversions, not page views
- Once a month, line up cost per booked job for each channel in one spreadsheet
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Local Services Ads cheaper than Google Ads?
Sometimes, but not always. LSA charges per lead, so you skip paying for clicks that never call, but lead prices in competitive trades and legal categories can be high. Search ads can beat LSA on cost per lead when keywords and landing pages are tight. Compare cost per booked job, not cost per click versus cost per lead.
Can I run Local Services Ads and Google Search ads at the same time?
Yes. They are separate auctions and separate placements, so running both does not raise your own costs by competing against yourself. Many local service businesses run both: LSA for the top of the page and Search ads for specific high value services. Track them separately so you can see which channel is producing booked jobs.
What is the difference between Google Guaranteed and Google Screened?
Google Guaranteed was the badge for home service businesses like plumbers and HVAC companies, and Google Screened was for professional services like law firms and financial planners. Both required background, license and insurance checks depending on the category. Google has been consolidating them under a single Google Verified label, so the badge shown may differ by market.
Do I get charged for bad Local Services Ads leads?
You are charged for leads Google considers valid, but you can dispute leads that are spam, outside your service area, for a job you do not offer, or from job seekers. Google also credits some invalid leads automatically. Review your lead inbox weekly, because disputes have to be filed within a limited window after the lead comes in.
The Bottom Line
There is no universal winner here. LSA rewards good reviews and fast phone answering, and Search ads reward careful keyword and landing page work. I personally manage every account at Enlightened Media, including both channels, and I look at cost per booked job before anything else. If you want a second look at what you are running now, request a free audit and I will go through it myself.
Ready to Talk to a Google Ads Specialist?
Jason reviews every submission personally. Free audit, no sales pitch, responds within 1 business hour.
Get My Free Audit →Or call directly: 504-229-0603